2. Bundesliga
Further transparency when it comes to refereeing decisions - with this goal in mind, a pilot project for announcing referee decisions in the stadium was launched for both the Bundesliga and Bundesliga 2 on Matchday 20.
As part of the project, a total of nine Bundesliga and Bundesliga 2 stadiums were readied for referees to announce their decisions relating to certain situations on the pitch via stadium loudspeakers. The pilot project, which was initiated by the DFL Football Commission and driven forward in close coordination between the DFL and DFB Schiri GmbH, was launched at five matches this weekend.
In the first such case in Germany's top flight, referee Robin Braun announced an offside call at the BayArena during the Matchday 20 encounter between defending Bundesliga champions Bayer Leverkusen and Hoffenheim, when a penalty for the home team had originally been called. “The penalty was checked: according to the pictures, there was (a player in) an offside position. That’s why the decision is: no penalty – offside,” the match official explained.
Watch: Robin Braun makes the Bundesliga's first referee stadium announcement on Matchday 20
As in this case, and going forward, the referee will always speak to the crowd when he has been in the review area pitchside to check a decision on the monitor - or when he changes a decision following an intervention of the video assistant. The announcement will be made via the microphone of the referee's headset and will be heard over the stadium loudspeakers.
The referee will inform the spectators which phase of match action has been reviewed, the result of the review and the final decision. The announcement will also be integrated into the live broadcast of the media partners.
This procedure, known internationally as "Public Announcement", will initially be trialled at selected Bundesliga and Bundesliga 2 locations. The following clubs have voluntarily agreed to take part in the test phase: FC Bayern München, Borussia Dortmund, Eintracht Frankfurt, SC Freiburg, Bayer 04 Leverkusen, RB Leipzig, Fortuna Düsseldorf, SpVgg Greuther Fürth, FC St. Pauli. On Matchday 20 of the Bundesliga and Bundesliga 2, the project was tested for the first time in the following games:
Ansgar Schwenken, DFL Director of Match Operations: "With this test phase, we want to further increase the transparency of referee decisions and ensure greater understanding among the fans. Spectators in the stadium and in front of the screens will gain a deeper insight into the referee's decision-making process following an intervention by the video assistant. The DFL Football Commission and DFB Schiri GmbH have jointly developed an important project here."
Knut Kircher, Managing Director of DFB Schiri GmbH: "Despite all the controversial discussions surrounding the video assistant, we want to continue working with the DFL and its clubs to help make referees' decisions in the stadium more transparent. We see the "Public Announcement" as a first clear step towards more clarification and have trained the procedures conscientiously with our referees. We are therefore confident that we can successfully support this new procedure, even if it will be unfamiliar at first."